Monday, February 5, 2007

Wanted: Kinder, Gentler Teachers

By Jacob H. W. Wolf


When my daughter was in the second grade of public school in Meadowbrook PA. A suburb of Philly, she came home everyday very upset and sometimes in tears. She told my wife and I that her teacher was very mean to her. My daughter had had no previous difficulties either in kindergarten or first grade. So I called the school and made an appointment for us to visit her teacher. We arrived at my daughter’s school at the appointed time. I told her teacher that my daughter was very upset with her attitude towards my daughter. After ? conversations her teacher said to me, “Mr. Wolf, what do you want mo to do?”


I said, “I want you to be kind loving and gentle with Lisa.”


She replied, angrily, “I can’t do that. I can only be myself!”


I was so shocked at the teachers’ response that I could hardly speak. I immediately had my daughter switched to another teacher. There were no problems with the new teacher. This episode reminded me of my own experience with my second grade teacher at a Philly public school. I was a rather timid child, and I remember that one day in school my second grade teacher, an old grey-haired women with a clubbed food, grabbed me by the neck and threw me down the aisle. I will never forget how humiliated I felt.


These two experience made me wonder at the acceptance criteria of teachers’ colleges for elementary school teachers. The first thing that a teachers’ college should consider when evaluating a prospective applicant for a teaching position in the elementary grades is, in my opinion, whether she is a kind, loving and gentle person. If she is not she will never be an effective teacher, because a child can sense the attitude of her teacher towards her if the child feels that the teacher’s attitude if not an accepting one, the child will learn very little.

No comments: